Does Qur'an in surah tariq Ayat 5-7 say that the sperm:water of human come between ribs& backbone.

Discussion in 'Tafsir' started by Oowais Qassim Ali, Dec 30, 2025.

Draft saved Draft deleted
  1. AbdalQadir

    AbdalQadir time to move along! will check pm's.

    Can you firstly introduce yourself, as in are you a subcontinental? Sunni (Barelwi), deobandi, confused neutral etc.?

    I ask because you straight away come with probing questions on Ala Hazrat's stances. One could assume you're deobandi under taqiyya, but some of your tags are annoying to the extent of sounding like it's coming from a closet Islamophobe. InshaAllah you're neither of those, but still an introduction is good.

    Secondly, write properly spaced out paragraphs and well punctuated, coherent sentences; and don't say you can't find your way around the text editor box. If that's the case, learn basic computing and word processing too.

    What is your aim for these questions - you wanna debate an Islamophobe or debate a critic of Ala Hazrat, or just wanna know Ala Hazrat's positions on this verse (and the other verse on the other thread)?

    The simplest tafsir is that it (fluid emerges from between ribs and backbone) is kinayah for a man and woman engaged in the process of conceiving.

    If you wanna engage with Islamophobes or something, you can take the 'science' angle for other verses where more directly empiricist wording is used, like 88:17 for instance.
     
  2. Mohd Farhan Ali

    Mohd Farhan Ali New Member

    In holy Quran Surah Al tariq Ayat 5-7 allah tells us that man is created form a gushing fulid which emerges from between ribs and backbone how is this possible and when we see ahle sunnat ala hazrat r a kunzul iman tafasir it quotes IBN ABBAS (R.A) in which he says that sperm is collected from all organs of male and most of it comes from brain to the backbone of male and in female the water come from between the bone of chest where the necklace worn PLEASE CLARIFY IT HOW IT IS POSSIBLE.
     

Share This Page