Separate names with a comma.
it is common sense. by default any such statement by pious and shariah-abiding people will be taken as a dream or ilham. and will be refuted and...
for some years now, i have been discussing this with friends (who happen to be ulama and muftis) and been telling them. the first time i read this...
it is understood to be either ilham or in a dream or a vision. ibn abbad al-shafiyi (not rundi) mentioned this in his mafakhir: [ATTACH]...
most certainly yes. isn't that rational? why should he be deemed a sunni when he rejects a key sunni precept?
yes. he is a tafdili and out of ahl al-sunnah.
and foudeh deliberately misrepresented sharif jurjani. see in his muqaddimah of fat'h al wadud, i have already quoted that according to foudeh's...
and why did he keep quiet - repeatedly assuring that he is just QUOTING facts? is this issue lesser than wahdat wujud on which he attacks akabir...
sh. foudeh is a good mutakallim of our time - but we do not accept his word as final and he can stumble hard at times, when he tries reasoning by...
unless people are deluded that these two people are far greater in ilm and taqwa and insight anything else compared to ulama and awliya ibn humam...
certainly. that person is a mubtadiy. such as the zaydiyah in yemen. --- who are these arab ulama? contemporaries are very lax and one cannot...
FR v20 p.246 this fatwa from 1312 AH. here alahazrat DOES takfir of nanotvi, his fanciful interpretation of khatam and those who follow him in...
FR v14 p.280 this fatwa is from 1335 AH. five years before alahazrat's passing. [ATTACH]
FR v7 p.114 portion of longer fatwa. here alahazrat considers prayer behind kazzabi (i.e. belief in imkan kazib) as makruh tahrimi - compared to...
FR v6 p.543 [ATTACH] one condition mentioned is: sahihul aqidah whose aqidah is according to that of ulama of haramayn. obviously, he meant...
FR v11 p345-346 see the third type of shia: [ATTACH] TYPE TWO: [ATTACH] THREE: [ATTACH]
no. see the other thread. https://sunniport.com/index.php?threads/fatawa-ridawiyyah-on-praying-behind-tafdili-tafzili.16423/
FR 20, p243 [ATTACH]
i will post various fatawa on prayer behind tafdilis or mubtadiyin : FR v6, p.622: [ATTACH]
that is also correct. in the one minute clip, the speaker admits the aqidah of the afzaliyyat of sayyiduna abu bakr, but shies away from naming...
it is makruh tahrimi to pray behind a tafzili. and invalid to do ba'yah with a tafzili - if the pir becomes a tafzili, his ba'yah is severed. the...
